Cozumel, Quintana Roo — The proposed fourth cruise pier in Cozumel has entered a legal battle after its promoters filed a lawsuit challenging the cancellation of the environmental permit issued by the Secretariat of Environment and Natural Resources (Semarnat). The legal action seeks to restore the previously granted authorization and resume development.
According to Lupita Cab, a representative of the environmental group Conservation, Research and Environmental Management of Cozumel, the lawsuit asks a federal judge to nullify Semarnat’s decision, arguing that sufficient grounds exist to keep the original permit valid. The court has already admitted the case, formally opening proceedings that will be reviewed over the coming weeks.
The litigation will focus on determining the legality of the permit revocation, analyzing technical and legal arguments from both sides. The court must decide whether Semarnat acted lawfully in canceling the permit or whether it should be reinstated, which would allow the project to move forward.
The proposal to build a fourth cruise pier has sparked ongoing debate in Cozumel, dividing economic sectors and environmental groups. Business leaders and project promoters argue that expanding port infrastructure would increase the island’s capacity to receive cruise ships, boost tourism, and generate greater economic benefits.
On the other hand, civil organizations and environmental activists have repeatedly opposed the project, warning of potential damage to coral reefs, water quality, and marine biodiversity — key elements of the island’s natural environment. These concerns were among the arguments cited during the review that led to the permit’s cancellation.
