Alux 33 Loses State Environmental Permit: What the Ruling Means for Buyers

Puerto Morelos, Quintana Roo — A federal court ruling has stripped the Alux 33 condominium project of its state environmental authorization after finding that Quintana Roo’s environmental agency had no authority to approve the development. The decision turns on the project’s interaction with a coastal wetland and mangrove ecosystem, which places its environmental review under federal jurisdiction.

For prospective buyers, the case illustrates why a sales listing, a municipal construction license and a state environmental document should not be treated as proof that a coastal project has every approval it needs. Each serves a different purpose, and one agency cannot substitute its authorization for another agency’s legally required review.

In indirect amparo case 959/2025-G-1, the Ninth District Court ruled that the Environmental Impact and Risk Directorate of Quintana Roo’s Secretariat of Ecology and Environment, or SEMA, was “not legally competent” to authorize Alux 33’s environmental impact assessment. The authorization at issue was contained in document SEMA/DS/SGPA/DIRA/1522/2025, file MIAO-011-VI-25-0109, dated June 24, 2025.

The court ordered SEMA to leave that resolution without effect, issue a replacement acknowledging its lack of jurisdiction and refrain from exercising powers reserved to the federal government. According to the organizations that brought the case, the judgment became final and SEMA complied through document SEMA/SPCA/DIRA/0648/2026, declaring its previous authorization void and itself legally unable to decide the application.

Why the Level of Government Matters

Mexico’s General Law on Ecological Balance and Environmental Protection, known as LGEEPA, assigns federal environmental review to certain projects affecting coastal ecosystems and to works in wetlands, coastal areas and connected waters. The Alux 33 judgment cites Article 28, Section X, concerning works and activities in those environments. The relevant federal authority is the Secretariat of Environment and Natural Resources, or Semarnat.

That does not mean every property near the sea is automatically prohibited from development. It means a project falling within the federal categories must obtain the required federal environmental decision; a state approval cannot fill that gap. The distinction is especially consequential around Puerto Morelos, where development sits close to mangroves, dunes and other connected coastal habitats.

The project’s own environmental impact study submitted to Semarnat describes a 664-square-meter site with mangrove vegetation, including white and red mangrove. It also recounts an earlier federal inspection concerning fill placed on the site without federal environmental authorization. A submitted impact study, however, is an application for review—not an approval to build.

The advocacy group Defending the Right to a Healthy Environment, or DMAS, says SEMA had previously issued a technical opinion warning that Alux 33 did not comply with NOM-022-SEMARNAT-2003, the standard governing protection of coastal wetlands with mangroves. The group cited mangrove removal and possible violations of the General Wildlife Law. It also pointed to objections raised by the National Commission of Protected Natural Areas, or Conanp, and to Semarnat’s denial of federal environmental impact authorization. Those points form part of the project’s contested regulatory history; the latest court ruling specifically resolves SEMA’s authority to grant the state permit.

The Construction License Was Challenged Separately

Alux 33 had also received municipal construction license PM-1616. In a separate case, amparo 515/2025-IV, the Third District Court ordered Puerto Morelos to leave that license without legal effect because the municipality had not established that the required federal environmental authorization existed. The ruling also barred the municipality from using that license to support later extensions, regularization, completion or occupancy approvals.

Together, the decisions affect two different documents: the municipal permission to build and the state environmental authorization. Neither judgment should be described as a determination of an individual purchaser’s ownership rights or as an automatic order resolving what will happen to the structure already built. Those questions require their own legal and administrative processes.

Wider Scrutiny of Coastal Projects

DMAS has asked authorities to review other SEMA permits involving mangroves, wetlands, coastal ecosystems and the federal maritime-terrestrial zone. “Quintana Roo’s environment cannot be left subject to administrative interpretations that contravene federal law,” the organization said. It has named Inna, Musa del Puerto, Uva de Mar, Sole Blue, Soulam, Bella Mare, Wilma and Piedra del Mar among developments it believes warrant scrutiny.

Those projects do not all have the same proven legal status as Alux 33. In its June 2025 inspection report, federal environmental prosecutor Profepa said it temporarily closed seven Puerto Morelos coastal works: six lacked federal environmental impact authorization, while a seventh exceeded the area it had been authorized to develop. Its named examples included Musa del Puerto, Uva de Mar, Sole Blu and Soulam; the report spelled another project Vilma, rather than “Wilma.” Profepa carried out a separate round of coastal inspections and temporary closures in May 2025. The agency’s reports establish what inspectors found at those times, but do not by themselves prove the present permit or construction status of every project on DMAS’s list.

DMAS alleges that construction or sales continued into 2026 despite some closure notices and that several developments subsequently obtained SEMA authorizations. Each allegation needs to be checked against the individual project’s current federal, state and municipal files.

For anyone considering a reservation deposit or purchase in a coastal development, the practical question is specific: Which permits apply to this parcel and this version of the project, who issued them, and are they still valid? Alux 33 shows why buyers should request the actual documents and have an independent Mexican real estate lawyer check them against the project’s environmental and court records before committing funds.

Discover more from Riviera Maya News

Sign up to receive a summary of the best news in your inbox, every day.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

By Ana Reyes

Ana Reyes covers environmental policy, conservation initiatives, infrastructure projects, and political developments across the Yucatán Peninsula for Riviera Maya News & Events. She reports on issues from sargassum management and reef conservation to the Maya Train, coastal development, and state and federal policy affecting Quintana Roo and the broader peninsula.Ana has covered environmental and political news since 2023, tracking key developments in Mexico's environmental regulations, coral reef protection, coastal zone management, and the intersection of tourism development with conservation efforts. Her reporting spans from Cancun's hotel zone to the Sian Ka'an Biosphere Reserve and the culturally significant regions of the Yucatán interior.Ana is fluent in English and Spanish, and draws from a wide range of sources including government environmental agencies, conservation organizations, academic researchers, and local community leaders to provide balanced, well-sourced coverage. She is particularly focused on how environmental policy decisions affect the daily lives of residents and the long-term sustainability of the region.For story tips: ana@rivieramayanews.mx