Playa del Carmen, Quintana Roo — The Playa del Carmen Public Security Department has opened an internal investigation into a complaint of alleged police abuse filed publicly by Canadian citizen Jeffrey Burke, who accused municipal officers of arbitrarily detaining, assaulting and extorting him during his stay in the resort town.
However, the department’s head, Carlos Montesinos, rejected several of the foreigner’s allegations and said the detention occurred under circumstances different from those described by the complainant.
In an interview, the official confirmed that the Internal Affairs Directorate opened a case on its own initiative after Burke’s complaint circulated. Burke identified himself as a retired Canadian police detective with about 20 years of service.
Montesinos said that as part of the initial inquiries, authorities obtained copies of the standardized police report, the National Detention Registry record and the medical certificate issued to the Canadian citizen.
He added that security camera recordings from the business where the incident occurred were also added to the file, along with footage captured inside the department’s own facilities.
Police say arrest followed convenience store incident
According to the secretary, the police intervention did not occur where or for the reasons Burke described. Burke had linked his arrest to a dispute over the use of a beach lounger in the tourist zone.
Montesinos said the events began at a convenience store in the Sasil-Há neighborhood, where, according to information gathered by Internal Affairs, the Canadian allegedly opened a bottled soft drink without paying for it.
He added that the foreigner allegedly became aggressive toward store employees, prompting staff to call the 911 emergency line and request municipal police.
According to the official, when officers arrived they twice asked the tourist to leave the premises, but he allegedly insisted on going back inside and continued to behave aggressively.
“That is how the decision was made to detain him for an administrative offense and turn him over to the civic judges,” he said.
The secretary said the officers acted on the store’s request for help, not because of a conflict over the use of beach facilities.
Official says videos show no assault
One of the central points of the controversy is Burke’s account of how he was treated during his arrest.
Montesinos said Internal Affairs obtained recordings from inside and outside the store, provided by the business’s legal representative.
Footage was also recovered from Public Security facilities, particularly from the moment the foreigner was taken to the medical area for his certificate before being brought before the civic judges.
According to the secretary’s interpretation, the recordings show no blows or hostile behavior by officers toward the Canadian.
“At no point, from the video recordings I mentioned inside the business, nor outside when he is detained by police and taken to a patrol car, is it observed that the officers assaulted him, hit him or behaved hostilely toward the Canadian tourist,” he said.
The official did not say whether the recordings will be released publicly or made available to the complainant so they can be compared with his testimony.
Official denies officers destroyed his glasses
Montesinos also specifically rejected Burke’s accusation that his glasses were destroyed during the arrest.
He said the cameras show the foreigner wearing them from the moment of the police intervention until his arrival at the department’s facilities.
He even said that in the photograph taken during the booking process, the glasses can be seen resting on the Canadian’s shirt at chest height.
“It is completely false that municipal police destroyed his glasses during the detention,” he said.
The secretary said the investigation also includes testimony from the store’s private security staff, who allegedly requested police intervention.
According to his account, that statement documents the reasons for the emergency call and the behavior that, according to the workers, Burke displayed while at the store.
Investigation remains open; extortion allegation unresolved
Despite rejecting much of the Canadian citizen’s accusations, Montesinos said the administrative investigation remains open and the department is willing to cooperate with other authorities to clarify what happened.
“The investigation continues on its own initiative,” he said.
The official added that the Public Security Department is willing to cooperate with consular authorities and the Quintana Roo State Prosecutor’s Office.
More Law Enforcement
- Federal Agents Raid Home in Playa del Carmen’s Colosio Neighborhood
- Homeless Man Found Dead in Wheelchair on Playa del Carmen’s Fifth Avenue
- Worker Killed in Slab Collapse at Riu Hotel Construction Site in Isla Mujeres
- Women’s Safety in Quintana Roo Has Deteriorated, Activist Group Says
- Quintana Roo Governor Says Prosecutor’s Office Must Explain Arrest of Former Playa del Carmen Mayor
More Playa del Carmen
- Xcaret Secures Winter Bookings After a Difficult Year for the Riviera Maya
- 60 Cenotes in Yucatan Peninsula to Be Monitored for Contamination
- University in Playa del Carmen Opens New Archery Range
- Playa del Carmen Sees More Tourists but Weaker Spending on Fifth Avenue
- Quintana Roo Launches Targeted Mpox Vaccination Campaign With Jynneos

