Holbox’s High Costs Hurt Locals and Scare Off Tourists

Holbox, Quintana Roo — The economy of families on Holbox Island is being constrained by the refusal of some established businesses to allow new enterprises that could offer products at more accessible prices. The opposition is based on the argument that these investments would affect the "tranquility" of the island, but as a consequence, prices for basic necessities remain excessively high.

Juan Manuel Rico Santa, a tourism service provider, denounced that a well-known convenience store attempted to set up on the island a few months ago but was rejected due to protests from local merchants. The conflict escalated to state authorities, preventing the opening of a business that, according to Rico Santa, would have directly benefited the household economy of residents.

"The prices for the basic food basket are through the roof. The merchants say it's because of maritime transportation costs, but that could be solved with a convenience store that offers better prices," he stated.

The impact of high costs not only affects locals but also national tourism. Rico Santa commented that many Mexican visitors leave disappointed by the high prices of lodging, food, and basic products. Although tourism continues to arrive, he warned that a reduction in prices could attract a greater number of national visitors.

For his part, a top-level official indicated that the cost of a ferry ticket exceeds 200 pesos per person for both national and international users. Only local residents, identified with an INE credential, have access to preferential rates. "In comparison with Cozumel or Isla Mujeres, the prices in Holbox are considerably higher," the official pointed out.

José Cruz, a small merchant near the main park, also acknowledged the problem. He recounted that when his grandchildren visit from Playa del Carmen, they prefer to take a trip to the neighboring port of El Cuyo, in Yucatán, where the total expense, including transportation, food, and drinks, is less than half of what a stay in Holbox would cost.

Resistance to change and a lack of commercial competition appear to be key factors keeping Holbox's economy expensive for both locals and tourists. Meanwhile, families continue to face a high cost of living, and national tourism, one of the main sources of income, is being deterred by disproportionate prices.